
8
Selling a Vibe
The Cribs
For two decades, The Cribs have been control freaks. They’ve never worked with the same producer twice. They’ve cycled through Steve Albini, Dave Fridmann, Ric Ocasek, Edwyn Collins—each time getting the exact sound they wanted and moving on. On Selling a Vibe, the Jarman brothers finally let go.
For the first time, The Cribs handed full control to producer Patrick Wimberly, the former Chairlift member known for his work with Solange, MGMT, and Caroline Polachek. Despite coming from the pop world, his production choices didn’t change who the band is. Because The Cribs’ identity was never in the fuzz or the lo-fi aesthetic or the DIY production choices. Their identity is fraternal.
“We entirely gave the reins over,” Gary Jarman said in an interview with Northern Transmissions. He flew to New York for the sessions with nothing but a bass in a gig bag, deliberately leaving the baggage behind, both literal and otherwise. The whole album was tracked in a week at Wimberly’s Brooklyn studio, as fast as they’ve worked since their debut. That speed wasn’t reckless. It was trust. Trust in a producer, yes, but more fundamentally, trust that twenty years of being brothers in a band had built something that couldn’t be dismantled by someone else’s mixing choices.
The result is their most sonically polished record, and somehow their most emotionally direct. Mixed by Lars Stalfors (St. Vincent, The Mars Volta), the hooks land with new force, the guitars gleam where they once scraped, and the melodies that spent years buried under DIY grit now occupy the foreground. Ross Jarman called it their “pop phase,” the moment the band finally shed what he described as “punk rock guilt.” But that framing undersells what’s actually happening. This isn’t The Cribs going pop. This is The Cribs revealing that they were always pop, underneath the static and the scrappiness.
What Wimberly gave them was space. Previous Cribs records often felt urgent and claustrophobic – Every frequency fighting for attention, the hooks struggling against layers of fuzz and urgency. Selling a Vibe breathes. There is air between the instruments now, room for the vocals to land. It feels like three brothers making music because they still want to.
“A Point Too Hard to Make” landed on the BBC 6 Music A-list, and even a casual listen explains why – it’s immediate, anthemic, built around a hook that lodges in your head. “Never the Same” has an even stranger origin: the Jarmans wrote it in Wakefield after returning from Louis Tomlinson’s Away From Home festival in Italy, where they’d been discussing writing tracks for his next album. They knocked it out in a couple of hours, liked it too much to give away, and it wound up on Selling a Vibe instead.
The album closes with ‘Brothers Won’t Break,’ recorded not in Wimberly’s Brooklyn studio but in a basement in Portland. It sounds exactly like the rest of the record, which is the point. “There could never be any shame for the things that we would never change,” they sing together. “After all this time holding the line.” Gary admitted he felt self-conscious bringing those lyrics to his brothers. It’s not something they’d ever said to each other explicitly. But after weathering an 18-month legal battle that nearly ended the band, after years living on different continents, after Night Network broke their streak of four consecutive UK Top 10 albums, they stopped dancing around what holds them together.
In conversation, Gary talked about reaching a point where he’d made peace with The Cribs never making another record. That clarity—the absence of desperation—is what allowed them to finally let someone else in. They weren’t protecting an identity anymore. They were just being one.
Other bands hire outside producers to find themselves. The Cribs hired one and proved they never needed to.
Pre-order Selling A Vibe by The Cribs HERE
Latest Reviews
Tracks
Related Albums
Related News
Advertisement
Join the Northern Transmissions insiders list
Sign up for reviews, interviews, news, videos, playlists — and more.












